When I arrived at my client’s barn I noticed my 4 legged client looked quite different than the last time I saw her about 20 months ago. Where she used to be convex on all saddle bearing surfaces, she was now concave. My updated tracing showed a different horse than I had seen or than the saddle seller ever saw. The story was that this mare had lost about 300 lbs and was now back to working 3rd level dressage. The cause of the weigh loss was never clearly diagnosed and there had been 2 barn changes in the meantime. I was called because the chiropractor thought there may have been something going on with her saddle.
To the layman’s eye the saddle looked good from the front and back. The trainer didn’t have any problem with it. What had never been noticed was that this saddle was now pivoting in the center, under the rider’s seat, and hanging there on there horse’s spine. My exam before I placed the saddle on this poor horse’s back yielded drastic pain reaction to pressure on both sides from the end of the withers through to about the sacrum. Neither the owner or the professional trainer were aware of any problem.
My Point in relaying this story is that a saddle should never even be placed on a horse’s back if a horse has gone through body changes if the saddle fit has not been evaluated by a professional saddle fitter. To the eye, this saddle looked acceptable by what most people would judge. That this horse is working 3rd level dressage, lifting her back and incurring pain each time, is certainly what no owner, including her owner, would ever want if they understood what they had been asking.
If you are aware that your horse has changed weight, either up or down, be sure to have a saddle fitter take a look before you put that saddle on again. Even if it looks good, a saddle fitter knows aspects of fit that trainers and riders are not aware of. It can save your horse unnecessary pain and can save you future vet calls.
If you have worked with me or read my articles you probably know my answer… “It Depends”. There are differing levels of trainer involvement for each one of us so there are different considerations for their involvement in your saddle selection.
If you take lessons and very occasionally the trainer hops on your horse to illustrate a technique or make a correction, they should always be asked to view you in a perspective saddle in order to confirm that it places you in a correct position. They should also have a long enough history with you to establish that your riding is as good, or better in this saddle than in your previous one. If your saddle fitter has determined that the saddle is a good fit for you and your horse, and the trainer gives her blessing based on a visual evaluation, you are good to go!
If both you and your trainer are riding your horse on a regular basis, determine who your new saddle is really for. I have some clients whose taste in saddles and whose builds differ enough from their trainers’ that they bite the bullet and purchase two saddles. If this is not in your cards, work with your saddle fitter to identify separate saddles that will accommodate you and your trainer and that work well for your horse. An alternative is to ask your saddle fitter to guide you through the fitting process that will best accommodate you, your trainer, and the horse with one saddle. There are no hard and fast rules but the saddle fitter will be able to point out the impact on the horse of, say, a saddle that is too small versus too large in the seat for a rider. My bottom line as a fitter is always the horse but if the saddle is unsuited for the rider, the horse will feel the discomfort also.
Finally there are the owners whose horses are in full training. If this is going to be for an extended period, consider purchasing a saddle that fits the trainer then trading it in for one that fits you when the time comes for your partnership with your horse. I am a firm believer in the used saddle market and encourage clients to buy and sell as their needs change.By the time your horse has matured with professional training, odds are that he or she will need a new saddle anyway.
Some trainers have saddles that can be used on a variety of horses. That said, trainers are not professional saddle fitters and I have seen a great deal of damage done to performance horses by trainers’ saddles. It never hurts to have your saddle fitter check any saddle that will be used on your horse. Trust me, it is WAY cheaper than having the hocks and stifles injected because your horse is compensating for pain in the back.
One caveat to observe when looking for a saddle: keep an open mind! Some professional trainers have saddle preferences which work well for them and sometimes they are sponsored or have deals with saddle companies. Do not let their preferences or prejudices in saddle choices affect your selection process. Saddle companies make saddles in a way that will suit certain riders and certain horses. We, and our horses, are all built differently and we react differently to a saddle. Work with an independent saddle fitter who knows the quality and characteristics of many saddles and who can steer you toward the best for your unique needs.